Pizza My Heart

Restaurant · PizzaSan Mateo

No dishes marked gluten free36 can be made gluten free on request

55 dishesmenu read 11 Novpizzamyheart.com

Always confirm with staff

DirectionsWebsite
MoreClose
Call

This menu is shared by 5 venues and read once for all of them.

Badges show only what the menu states. Dashed “Likely …”: our guess from the ingredients. Anything else: not listed, so ask staff.

Pizza menu (online)

Award Winning Pizzas

  • Big Sur$12

    40 cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, portobello mushrooms & green onions. Our most popular and…

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Little Sur$12

    40 cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato pizza sauce, roasted red peppers, portobello mushrooms, green onions, cherry tomatoes & herbs.…

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Virgin Creek$12

    Fresh basil, garlic, ricotta & Roma tomatoes.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Watsonville Apple$12

    Freshly sliced green apple, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green onions, gorgonzola, olive oil & garlic.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Fort Point$12

    Light tomato & pesto sauce (made with almonds) with Roma tomatoes, chicken, ricotta, sausage, artichoke, basil & herbs.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairyLikely nuts

Specialty Pizzas With Meat

  • Big Sur$12

    Our most popular specialty pizza. 40 cloves of roasted garlic, pepperoni, sausage, portobello mushrooms & green onions.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Maui Wowie$12

    Lots of real Canadian bacon with plenty of juicy pineapple.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Cowell's Combo$12

    A classic with all time favorite toppings. Pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms, onions & bells.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Maverick's$12

    A carnivore's delight. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & Canadian bacon.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Sunset Beach$12

    Real Canadian bacon, bacon, red onions, bells & pineapple.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Davenport$12

    Sausage, spinach, garlic, mushrooms & onions.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Doheny Sweet Heat$12

    Savory & sweet with pepperoni, sausage, pickled peppers, ricotta and a drizzle of hot honey.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Wingnut's$12

    Pepperoni, red onions & mushrooms. Named after a favorite customer from Capitola.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • D'Lex Chicken & Bacon$12

    Chicken, bacon, mushrooms, garlic, green onions in a white sauce. Named after a favorite customer from Santa Cruz.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Watsonville Apple$12

    Green apple slices, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green onions, gorgonzola, olive oil & garlic. Best Gourmet Pizza West Coast Pizza…

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Rockaway$12

    A taste of summer anytime with our own zesty BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, topped with fresh cilantro.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Depot Hill$12

    Sundried tomatoes, our own recipe pesto & grilled chicken.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely nuts

  • Pleasure Point$12

    A classic Santa Cruz surf break and favorite pizzas. Garlic, Roma tomatoes, spinach & chicken.

    Can be made free of gluten

Vegan & Vegetarian Specialty Pizzas

  • Manresa$12

    Always a favorite! White pizza with fresh basil, garlic, Romas & ricotta.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Pesto$12

    Our own recipe with basil, garlic, Parmesan & almonds.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairyLikely nuts

  • The Mt. Diablo - Vegan$12

    Vegan pizza with plant-based mozzarella, Beyond Meat hot Italian sausage, garlic, fresh mushrooms, pickled peppers and fresh parsley.

    VegetarianCan be made free of gluten

  • Little Sur$12

    Lots of veggie and big time flavors. 40 cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato pizza sauce, roasted red peppers, portobello mushrooms…

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Prima$12

    Roma tomatoes, feta, olives & Parmesan.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • The Hook$12

    Our favorite vegetarian combo. Tomatoes, olives, bells, mushrooms, artichoke, red onion & Parmesan.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • Castroville$12

    Inspired by the local farm fields. Almond basil pesto, spinach, artichoke hearts, cherry tomatoes & feta cheese.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairyLikely nuts

  • Vegan Big Sur$12

    Our favorite vegan pizza. 40 cloves of roasted garlic, Prime Roots vegan pepperoni, Beyond Meat Italian sausage, portobello mushrooms, and…

    VeganCan be made free of gluten

  • Linda Mar$12

    Spinach, garlic, artichokes, broccoli, olives & Romas.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • Virgin Creek$12

    Our signature pizza sauce with fresh basil, garlic, ricotta, Roma tomatoes and a dusting of herbs and spices.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • The Mendocino - Vegan$12

    Plant-based mozzarella, pizza sauce, Roma tomatoes and garlic. Topped with breadcrumbs, fresh basil and drizzled olive oil.

    VegetarianCan be made free of gluten

Design Your Own Pizza

  • Cheese Pizza$12

    The original and still a favorite. Made with real California cheese and vine-ripened tomatoes.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • 1 Topping Pizza$12

    Choose any one topping. Our old-school pepperoni is a classic.

    Can be made free of gluten

  • 2 Toppings Pizza$12

    Choose any two toppings. Meat: pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, bacon, anchovies. Veggie: mushrooms, red onions, bells, tomatoes…

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

  • 3 Toppings Pizza$12

    Choose any three toppings (see 2 Toppings for the topping list; pesto contains almonds).

    Can be made free of glutenLikely nuts

  • 4 Toppings Pizza$12

    Choose any four toppings (see 2 Toppings for the topping list; pesto contains almonds).

    Can be made free of glutenLikely nuts

  • Heart Shaped Pizza$29.75

    A 14" 2-topping pizza in the shape of a heart.

    Likely gluten

Snacks & Salads

  • Chicken Wings$10.99

    Freshly baked wings served with buffalo or BBQ sauce. Ask for ranch or blue cheese.

  • Boneless Chicken Wings$10.99

    Oven-baked boneless wings made with 100% all white meat. Served with buffalo or BBQ dipping sauce. Add house ranch or blue cheese at no…

    Likely dairy

  • Bread Stix$8.50

    Our own bread stix with fresh garlic, olive oil and a sprinkle of Parmesan. Ask for ranch dressing or pizza sauce.

    Likely glutenLikely dairy

  • Classic Caesar Salad$9

    Romaine lettuce, garlic croutons, Parmesan & a classic Caesar dressing.

    Likely glutenLikely dairyLikely eggLikely fish

  • Greek Salad$7.75

    Romaine lettuce, onions, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, artichokes, red onion & tomatoes.

    Likely dairy

  • Seasonal Greens$7.75

    Mixed baby greens, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes & broccoli. Choose your favourite dressing including house-made ranch.

  • Chicken Walnut Salad$9.75

    Mixed baby greens, candied walnuts, chicken, gorgonzola with our own balsamic dressing.

    Likely dairyLikely nuts

  • Kook-ie$7.50

    Oversized chocolate chip cookie with 8 delicious slices.

    Likely gluten

  • Cinna-Bomb$7.50

    Pizza dough baked with cinnamon and spices, then topped with a drizzle of icing. Sliced for sharing.

    Likely gluten

Slices with Meat

  • Old-School Pepperoni Slice$6

    An all time classic. Always nitrate and nitrite free!

  • The Big Sur Slice$6.75

    The favorite specialty slice with pepperoni, sausage, portobello, roasted garlic & green onion.

  • D'Lex Chicken & Bacon Slice$6.75

    Hormone-free chicken, bacon, mushrooms, green onions and creamy garlic sauce.

    Likely dairy

  • Maui Wowie Slice$6.75

    Real Canadian bacon and lots of juicy pineapple. Aloha!!

  • Pepperoni & Sausage Slice$6.75

    Always a tasty classic.

Slices Without Meat

  • Cheese Slice$5.50

    Vine ripened tomatoes and California mozzarella cheese.

    Likely dairy

  • Pesto Slice$6

    Basil, garlic, almonds & Parmesan. An all-time favorite.

    Likely dairyLikely nuts

  • Super Veggie Slice$6.75

    Roma tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions, black olives, bell peppers and marinated artichoke hearts.

    Vegetarian

  • Manresa Slice$6

    Basil, garlic, tomatoes & ricotta.

    Likely dairy

Hand-held menu (PDF, 7-24)

Specialty Pies with Meat

  • Chicken Joe$12

    Chicken, pesto, artichoke, cherry tomatoes, feta cheese & fresh basil.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairyLikely nuts

Specialty Vegetarian Pies

  • Prima$12

    Roma tomatoes, feta, black olives, Parmesan.

    Can be made free of glutenLikely dairy

The menu’s own key: Leaf symbol denotes vegan item. Calories listed do not include salad dressing.

What the menu saysGluten free rice flour crusts available on 12" pizzas on request (printed on the menu). Menu also states: all items are prepared in a shared kitchen, so some cross contamination is possible on all products.
  • Gluten free rice flour crusts available on 12" pizzas on request (printed on the menu). Menu also states: all items are prepared in a shared kitchen, so some cross contamination is possible on all products.
  • Allergy guide: all food is prepared in a shared kitchen and may contain traces of allergens not specific to that item. Per-dish allergen matrix could not be mapped reliably from the extracted text (dot positions lost), so allergen fields rely on printed ingredients and statements only.

Good to know

Restaurant

  • Vegetarian dishes (2)venue menu, read 1 Nov 2026
  • Vegan dishes (1)venue menu, read 1 Nov 2026

Not known yet: dog friendly, kid friendly, kids menu, outdoor seating, wheelchair access, high chairs, takes bookings, byo, baby change. Ask the venue.

Facts

FactDetail
Address140 East 4th Avenue, San Mateo
AreaPeninsula
KindRestaurant · Pizza
Phone+1-650-344-9800
Websitepizzamyheart.com
Menu read11 Nov 2026 from pizzamyheart.com
Hours
  • Monday11am–10pm
  • Tuesday11am–10pm
  • Wednesday11am–10pm
  • Thursday11am–10pm
  • Friday11am–10pm
  • Saturday11am–10pm
  • Sunday11am–10pm
MapOpen in Google Maps

What diners say

No diner ratings yet.

Ratings are diners’ own experience. They don’t make a dish safe; neither do we.

Where this comes from

Allergen answers come from the menu’s labels first, then the listed ingredients, then a model’s judgement checked when unsure. How allergen status is decided.

Questions about Pizza My Heart

Does Pizza My Heart have gluten-free options?

No dish is marked gluten free as served, and 36 more can be made gluten free on request, from the menu read 11 Nov 2026. Each dish shows whether the venue labelled it or it was read from the ingredients.

Is Pizza My Heart coeliac friendly?

The venue notes: “Gluten free rice flour crusts available on 12" pizzas on request (printed on the menu).”. Eatcrush reads each venue’s own menu and says where every answer came from. It never calls a dish safe: kitchens share fryers, boards and flour, and menus change. If you have coeliac disease or an allergy, confirm with staff before you order.

What can be made gluten free at Pizza My Heart?

Big Sur (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request); Little Sur (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request); Virgin Creek (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request); Watsonville Apple (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request); Fort Point (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request); Big Sur (GF rice flour crust on 12" pizza on request).

When is Pizza My Heart open?

Monday: 11am–10pm. Tuesday: 11am–10pm. Wednesday: 11am–10pm. Thursday: 11am–10pm. Friday: 11am–10pm. Saturday: 11am–10pm. Sunday: 11am–10pm. Hours can change on public holidays; check with the venue.

Nearby